Round 20 what can happen?

SENIORS

SATURDAY
Geelong(9-8 8th) vs Collingwood(9-8 7th) at Skilled Stadium 9:40am
Pretty simple equation Winner finishes 7th,Loser finishes 8th

Port Melbourne(12-5 3rd) vs Williamstown(12-5 2nd) at TEAC Oval 1:10pm
Possible rehearsal for qualifying final. Williamstown can still finish top if North Ballarat lose to Sandringham. Willy can't finish lower than 3rd. Port Melbourne can not finish higher than 2nd but could finish as low as 4th depending on how the Bullants go against Frankston.

North Ballarat(13-4 1st) vs Sandringham(7-10 7th) at Eureka Stadium 2pm
North Ballarat win and it is the minor premiership if they lose they can drop to 2nd if Williamstown defeat Port Melbourne. Its Sandy's final game of the season with either a 9th or 10th place finish

SUNDAY
Box Hill Hawks(11-6 5th) vs Casey Scorpions(10-7 6th) at Box Hill 2pm
If Box Hill win they can finish as high as 4th if the Bullants lose to Frankston. If Casey win Casey they too could finish as high as 4th if the Bullants lose to Frankston. A loss to either team will mean a 6th place finish.

Frankston(3-14 12th) vs Northern Bullants(11-6 4th) at Frankston 2pm
If the Bullants win they can finish as high as 3rd should Williamstown defeat Port Melbourne. A loss and it will miss the double chance and finish 5th. Frankston's will finish 12th having all ready recorded their worst season in the new VFL(since 2000).

Werribee(7-10 11th) vs Bendigo Bombers(0-17 13th) at Windy Hill 2pm
Neither side can play finals. This represents Bendigo's last chance to win a game this season.

BYE-Coburg Tigers(7-11 10th) Coburg's season is over.

RESERVES
SATURDAY
Port Melbourne(5-12 9th) vs Williamstown(14-3 2nd) at TEAC Oval 10:20am
Williamstown can finish top with a win should Casey defeat Box Hill. Can not finish lower than 2nd so will have 1st week of finals off and go straight to Preliminary Finals. This is Port's final game of the season.

North Ballarat(10-7 4th) vs Sandringham(8-8 6th) at Eureka Stadium 11:10am
This is the big reserves game of the weekend. If North Ballarat win they will finish 3rd if they lose they can finish as low as 5th. For Sandy it is all or nothing if they win they finish 6th and make the finals if they lose they have to hope Bendigo Bombers defeat Werribee on Sunday an unlikely outcome. If this happens Sandy will only miss the finals by match ratio because they(along with Bendigo) played one less game than the rest of the teams.

SUNDAY
Box Hill Hawks(14-3 1st) vs Casey Scorpions(7-10 8th) at Box Hill 11:10am
A win for Box Hill and they win the minor premiership. A loss they can only finish as low as 2nd if Williamstown def Port Melbourne. Regardless of result they will have a week off and go straight through to the Preliminary Finals. This is Casey's last game of the season.

Frankston(10-7 5th) vs Northern Bullants(5-12 10th) at Frankston 11:10am
A win for the Dolphins and they will finish either 3rd or 4th. A loss and they will remain in 5th. This is the Bullant's final game of the season.

Bendigo Bombers(1-15 11th) vs Werribee(8-9 7th) at Windy Hill 11:10am
Werribee will know going into this game the result from the North Ballarat vs Sandringham game, If North Ballarat have won they will need to defeat Bendigo to make the finals in 6th place. If Sandringham have won they will only be playing for pride. This is Bendigo's last game for the season and who knows maybe their last reserves game ever.

BYE-COBURG TIGERS(11-7 3rd) Coburg will be playing in the finals and can finish anywhere between 3rd and 5th.

Forums
caseyscorp Wed, 26 Aug 2009 - 21:54

Robbo wrote:Caseyscorp, It is on best fit not on poistion. Port Melbourne will play their final at Port regardless of result against Willy this week. It is just a matter of whether a game will be played at Box Hill or Casey Fields.

Regardless of "best fit", if Willy beat Port & finishes 2nd, and Port finishes 3rd, watch the feathers fly as Willy tries to get a "home" final.

vfa Wed, 26 Aug 2009 - 22:17

Of course it should be played at Williamstown if the seagulls win, likewise if Port win it should be at Teac Oval.
The fools running the VFL should state this now therefore the prize for winning on Saturday for the arch rivals is a home final.
Grow some balls VFL !!!

Robbo Topic starter Thu, 27 Aug 2009 - 09:12

I say again I got an email from AFL Victoria on Monday Port will be playing at Port regardless of result of Saturday's game.

footyman Thu, 27 Aug 2009 - 10:02

That genuinely stinks Robbo, because Port are very, very hard to beat at home. If Willy finish higher, they deserve to host a final at Point Gellibrand.

This has been an issue for years - this "best fit" thing is a nonsense. Time to ditch it and come up with a fair system - perhaps 1st and 2nd should be guaranteed home finals in week 1. Or as I've said before, do away with the ABC coverage on the Sunday in Week 1 and play all four finals at the grounds of 1st, 2nd, 5th and 6th with the ABC showing just the Saturday game as per normal.

digs Thu, 27 Aug 2009 - 10:11

footyman wrote:That genuinely stinks Robbo, because Port are very, very hard to beat at home. If Willy finish higher, they deserve to host a final at Point Gellibrand.

This has been an issue for years - this "best fit" thing is a nonsense. Time to ditch it and come up with a fair system - perhaps 1st and 2nd should be guaranteed home finals in week 1. Or as I've said before, do away with the ABC coverage on the Sunday in Week 1 and play all four finals at the grounds of 1st, 2nd, 5th and 6th with the ABC showing just the Saturday game as per normal.

IF ? the Roosters finish on top there is no certainty that they will host a final.
The best fit scenario is bulls**t.
Just reward the teams that deserve the home games by finishing ahead of their opponents.

vfa Thu, 27 Aug 2009 - 10:29

Williamstown will be absolutely fuming if they do beat Port and finish second and have to play at Port again the following week.
Absolute crap that the lower ranked teams can play at home during the first week of finals against their higher ranked opposition.
What happens to the reward for finishing higher ?
The only fairest way to do in week one is for teams one, two, five and six all play at home in week one. Forget about Teac Oval. No arguements and you know where you stand. Unless of course Port finishes one, two, five or six.

Week two and three all finals at Teac Oval.

The Grand Final ?? If Shocklands is a flop again this year forget about it.
Hopefully they can get a better crowd this year.
Jury of course is out to where the GF would be played in 2010 if this years GF is poor again.
But for the first week of finals is so simple, reward the teams 1,2,5 and 6 a home ground advantage for week one. How simple is this.

You can bet your balls Box Hill would have a home final for week one irrispective of where they will finish. Long odds on. Phar Lap odds.

Mustang Thu, 27 Aug 2009 - 10:50

If Box Hill get a home final it will be because:

1. It will most likely play an AFL Reserves team, each without a suitable venue to host a VFL final.

2. City Oval is a well appointed venue with outstanding playing surface, player facilities and (now) social amenities.

3. City Oval is a popular venue with a proven ability to attract spectators.

The real mystery here is why does Port Melbourne remain the VFL's venue of choice for the finals series? It has many, many shortcomings for finals games. Is it just to appease the ABC so they can set up there for 3 weeks and not have to relocate their OB unit? The ABC who support the competition so well that they won't broadcast the Grand Final live this year for the first time since the 1980s?

footyman Thu, 27 Aug 2009 - 11:21

Mustang wrote:The real mystery here is why does Port Melbourne remain the VFL's venue of choice for the finals series? It has many, many shortcomings for finals games. Is it just to appease the ABC so they can set up there for 3 weeks and not have to relocate their OB unit? The ABC who support the competition so well that they won't broadcast the Grand Final live this year for the first time since the 1980s?

Port = location. Central. 2km from the city. Plenty of shelter for spectators if it rains.

I hate Box Hill City Oval, sorry but its a huge, wide, difficult viewing ground that is not spectator friendly. It has limited shelter if its wet and poor car parking.

vfa Thu, 27 Aug 2009 - 11:22

It will be the first time since 1966 the VFA/VFL have not had the GF televised live ??
The replay of this years GF will be shown at the delayed time of 10pm with also a replay at midday on AFL Grand Final day. How many people would watch that on midday on AFL Grand Final day. What a joke.

I will be at the VFL GF of course and will pre tape it for 10pm.

So this year will be the first time it won't be televised since Port beat Waverely at North Port in the 1966 VFA GF.
Forty three years run broken.

What would happen if this years VFL GF was a draw ?
Where would the replay be played ?
Shocklands ? Seriously where would it be played because if it was drawn they would have no idea what to do.
Princes/Visy Park is not an option.
If you asked John Hook or Peter Schwab that question you would get a shrug of the shoulders or a blank look ??