Yeah,with Nth Ballarat attracted about 6 Delisted Players last-season & there in the country why Is that the Dolphins can't pull some big name signings?? they rely on DandenongU/18 players & local players sometimes they may get 1 or 2 delisted AFL players?? what's the go there?? Dolphin help me out!...
ozybeer Tue, 15 Feb 2005 - 20:10
The reason frankston did not join a a.f.l club was becuse it did not want to be run by them.Frankston made the right decison to stay on thier own rather than the seconds to some a.f.l club .You just have to look at all the alligned clubs to see who runs the show,last year at frankston v preston the preston coach constantly referd to his team at 3/4 time as the seconds ie;come on fellers we can lift you saw what the FIRST did yesterday. Port melb players in different huddles for a.f.l listed and port players the list goes on Also when carlton made enquires about merging with frankston,frankston were told they would be under control of carlton.AS for trying to buy prem a few years ago what team dosent.The comp has terned into aa.f.l resereves no matter what anybody says,frankston should be congratulated for trying to stand up to the a.f.l
zebraman Tue, 15 Feb 2005 - 20:36
Ons...I too would prefer that the VFL clubds were stand alone.....however....survival is the word and I doubt if many clubs would have survived without an alliance.. I have driven past many of the old grounds....Oakleigh, Prahran, Camberwell,, Northcote, Brunswick etc....and where are these clubs now?....GONE So if it means survival then an alliance with an AFL club is the lesser of two evils.... The big plus is the standard of the competiition. The current VFL comp is stronger than the old VFA and the AFL reserves... Sure there are a couple of instances where the AFL club has virtually been taken over....we've been lucky at Sandy where Melbourne didn't want to change the colours or the name...Port have the same deal with the Kangaroos...Werribee with the BUlldogs.... I would rather be in alliance and still playing than be out of existence
Dolphin Tue, 15 Feb 2005 - 23:04
zebraman wrote:And if Frankston were supposedly courted by a number of AFL clubs then why on earth didn't they take up an offer?......
Don't give me supposedly! I wonder whether the clubs that are aligned are really still in existance. Will is the prime example. Port with the 2 huddles last year. Just don't give me supposedly
NorthPort Tue, 15 Feb 2005 - 23:22
Dolphin wrote:...Port with the 2 huddles last year...
The only time I can recall anything like that occurring was once, when Port were getting done at 3/4 time when at the conclusion of the normal huddle, Laidley grabbed a couple of North Melbourne players to let them know he thought they were letting the side down.
Dolphin Tue, 15 Feb 2005 - 23:33
Thats the point Ons. A coach from ANOTHER club, in another competition, taking guys in a Port jumper to another huddle. Its just not right. Not even once.
Dolphin Tue, 15 Feb 2005 - 23:54
Just so we are clear here, I am not having a crack at any club for aligning. They all went in knowing what they had. But I won't cop anybody suggesting that ANY club SHOULD align just because some have. In any event, I expect that the only other club that could survive without an alignment would be Port.
ozybeer Wed, 16 Feb 2005 - 13:46
I can tell you it happend in round 1 last year v frankston +i heard it was happening other rounds[to huddles at port][/quote]
Dolphin Wed, 16 Feb 2005 - 13:56
Not wanting to be picky, but it was Round 2 v Frankston. I have no idea if it happened at other times, thats for others to raise. BTW, this thread has kinda gone away from the heading. ONS, is it possible to move the lot to something like " How are alignments working?" Cheers
billythekid Thu, 17 Feb 2005 - 10:07
Two premierships later I think Sandringham would be very happy with the Melbourne alignment but good on Frankston for giving it a go . The problem I see for the Dolphins is that its been a pretty badly run club all the time its been in the VFA/VFL being dominated by one family and clique that think that they were the only peolpe that knew how to get success - well tell you what it hasn't worked and wont in the future either. Success is as we all know not only about how much money you have to squander its about how to adminiser a club successfully in all aspects.
jb Thu, 17 Feb 2005 - 21:17
Dolphin, the thread has gone off the track a bit. Would also like Willy to be stand alone, and couldn't tell you if the club would have survived by itself. But it is what it is and I'm lucky I can take my 5 year old to still see the blue and gold and have a kick at quarter time, like I did at that age. I like Lovett's idea of bringing young players through. Maybe they could also focus recruiting on decent players at aligned clubs who can't get a run in the ones who could be enticed across. Frankston has done remarkably well, given that they have been in the top flight since being promoted from Div 2 in '78 and have never had an easy beat season like Preston, Coburg and Willy have all suffered in the '90's.

Adsence Horizontal