Chris Mitchell- afl stooge ?

Worst summary I have ever seen written in today's Herald Sun. Shame on you Chris Mitchell. Was the hightlight of the weekend Josh Fraser or was it Paul Luciria. Chris Mitchell's summary is as follows- he mentions Josh Fraser, Paul Licuria, Lonie, Prestigiacomo, Wunke, Corey Jones, Sansbury and Tom Hawkins. The only vfl listed player he mentions is Jacob Spalding who played his 100th game. Licuria although just a vfl player I thought there were other players that could be mentioned before him. Monday's herald sun usually wrap up the Sunday games with brief reports on Saturday's games. Chris Mitchell, was the highlight of Saturday's games Tom Hawkins ? What about Port's great win or Williamstown win or the great game between Werribee v Frankston. Was yesterday's highlight Josh Fraser who is a very overated footballer ? For the record the Wundke kicked 7 goals for the roosters to Collingwood 6 goals. Typical afl crap. Does Chris Mitchell know anything about the old VFA or current vfl teams or players ? Give me Paul Amy anyday. My summary from yesterday would have been ROOSTERS THRASH INEPT PIES !!!! The roosters celebrated Jacob Spalding's 100th game with a thrashing of the very average and inept Collingwood team. That is more the highlight and not crap like Fraser hand up for AFL recall.
Forums
footyman Mon, 14 Jul 2008 - 09:35
Im with you there mate. Problem is I suspect he's a young journalist whose been handed the VFL/TAC Cup gig and he's probably writing what his bosses want him to. I think The Age and the Herald Sun both used the same photo of Fraser today. I'd love to see the mainstream coverage improve but it never will. Thank god for sites like localfooty.com.au and this one who give real match reports on the games.
burraburger Mon, 14 Jul 2008 - 09:35
Standard. These pathetic articles appear every week. And today in the Herald Sun apparently the surface at Port melbourne is under investigation after Courtney Johns done his knee.... But the surface survived the other 150 years.
StationHotel Mon, 14 Jul 2008 - 10:08
I agree with you burra burger i couldn't believe my eyes this morning when reading the VFL section i was not happy at all. It's time we get a decent VFL reporter who will actually report on the games not just talking about which AFL players managed to get a touch. I would love to hear what Justin Berry from Frankston thinks of these articles he is a player i'v got lots of respect for and has great a fantastic attack on the ball and really plays for the jumper. I read in an interview that he can't wait to meet the AFL players when they come back to the VFL so he can give them a nice touch up see how good they really are. When the AFl players come back to play VFL there hearts and minds are else where you can sugar coat all you like but that's the facts. The Herald sun is a big issue not only does it have 16 pages and a back page devoted to AFL it takes up the VFL section talking rubbish about Collingwoods Josh Fraser getting a recall in the AFL.......give a me a bucket please And as for an investigation on the Port Melbourne ground what a joke it's one of the best surfaces in Australia. Unlike Teltra dome or some other AFL grounds you will find out it's 2nd to none and is of a very high standard playing surface.
footyman Mon, 14 Jul 2008 - 10:15
StationHotel wrote:And as for an investigation on the Port Melbourne ground what a joke it's one of the best surfaces in Australia. Unlike Teltra dome or some other AFL grounds you will find out it's 2nd to none and is of a very high standard playing surface.
Or ANZ Stadium in Sydney, now thats a ground worthy of the title "death valley". Divots everywhere.
burraburger Mon, 14 Jul 2008 - 10:37
If anything the surface at Port Melbourne is a little soft underfoot. Too hard??? I dont think so. Ive played Cricket at that ground since 1995/96 and Im telling you its not hard! The sad thing about the articles that appear in the Age and Herald Sun is that the reporters are actually on instructions to name drop AFL players. Its very disappointing. I look forward to reading about the VFL games every week but this really annoys me. And I know theres plenty of others out there who will pick up Inside Fooball and and take a quick look at the back section to see if there is much VFL before they decide to buy it or not.
vfa Topic starter Mon, 14 Jul 2008 - 10:53
[EDITED - NorthPort]. I might have a sneak peek straight in the vfl column to see if there is anything worthwhile. I do read Phil's comments but it is not worth $6 for all the afl crap. The toe to toe column and the collectable sections are good but the rest of it ?? Jim Main's garbage is not worth one cent. I remember there was a liftout in the Sunday Observer called Allsport. There was at least 20 pages of sport and about 4 of these pages were on the VFA. This was around 1972/3/4. Billy the kid, zebraman and zebra dave you would probably remember these liftouts. I kept some of these and they were great. These days we have to read crap like Chris Mitchell talking about Josh Fraser.
theobserver Mon, 14 Jul 2008 - 11:06
I do enjoy the Age write up by Michael Sharky. He covers the actual games and doesn't worry about the so-called names.
Dolphin Mon, 14 Jul 2008 - 13:10
burraburger wrote:And today in the Herald Sun apparently the surface at Port melbourne is under investigation after Courtney Johns done his knee.... But the surface survived the other 150 years.
The Port Melbourne surface is inconsistent, and has cost Frankston games from about 6 players over the last 3 years. It shifts in many places, is a bog in the middle, and ithe practice wicket area is nowhere near safe. Don't kid yourselves, its pretty ordinary.
digs Mon, 14 Jul 2008 - 13:31
vfa wrote:Worst summary I have ever seen written in today's Herald Sun. Shame on you Chris Mitchell. Was the hightlight of the weekend Josh Fraser or was it Paul Luciria. Chris Mitchell's summary is as follows- he mentions Josh Fraser, Paul Licuria, Lonie, Prestigiacomo, Wunke, Corey Jones, Sansbury and Tom Hawkins. The only vfl listed player he mentions is Jacob Spalding who played his 100th game. Licuria although just a vfl player I thought there were other players that could be mentioned before him. Monday's herald sun usually wrap up the Sunday games with brief reports on Saturday's games. Chris Mitchell, was the highlight of Saturday's games Tom Hawkins ? What about Port's great win or Williamstown win or the great game between Werribee v Frankston. Was yesterday's highlight Josh Fraser who is a very overated footballer ? For the record the Wundke kicked 7 goals for the roosters to Collingwood 6 goals. Typical afl crap. Does Chris Mitchell know anything about the old VFA or current vfl teams or players ? Give me Paul Amy anyday. My summary from yesterday would have been ROOSTERS THRASH INEPT PIES !!!! The roosters celebrated Jacob Spalding's 100th game with a thrashing of the very average and inept Collingwood team. That is more the highlight and not crap like Fraser hand up for AFL recall.
Spot on VFA. Josh Fraser has a heart as big a split pea & reminds me of a boarding house cup of tea BIG & WEAK. It is time that Collingwood stopped pampering these pussies with all the adulation, the quarter time & three quarter time huddles were laughable with the 10 metre circular seperation between the players & supporters an insult. Also I dont know what right the Collingwood players had to stand inside the fence between the boundary line for three quarters whilst the VFL reserves game was being played. The umpires should have had the guts to tell to get back behind the fence, but thats Collingwood, bigger than the rest. Collingwood bring absolutely nothing to the VFL.
TheVoiceoftheB Mon, 14 Jul 2008 - 13:49
It's alright guys, next season you'll see change but forget the Sun, it'll be hopefully with the Age. Chris is going to write about the AFL players because that's how he's instructed to write, he's like an umpire, sometimes not all of the blame can be attatched to him. Why doesn't one of the whingers take action and write a few articles for inside footy? Instead of being negative all the time take action - just a thought - or keep sitting on the fence.