Round 11 - Collingwood v Williamstown

Williamstown teams. Seniors vs Collingwood B: Wight 37 ~ Meyer 25 ~ Picken 18 HB: Addison 22 ~ Cloke 34 ~ Jolley 4 C: Greene 3 ~ Johnson 10 ~ Stretton 27 HF: Hill 20 ~ McDougall 23 ~ Giansiracusa 79 F: Ward 14 ~ Little 6 ~ Tiller 35 R: Street 58 ~ Ray 75 ~ Harbrow 40 Int: Reid 28 ~ Wood 45 ~ Cook 17 ~ Lockwood 29 ~ O'Keefe 30 ~ Beaumont 5 ~ Barling 2 ~ Stack 19 ~ Galea 7 ~ McKenzie 9 ~ Langlands 21 ~ Rose 1 Reserves vs Bullants B: Cartelli 54 ~ Barling 2 ~ Keddell 47 HB: McKenzie 9 ~ Boyd 26 ~ Beaumont 5 C: White 41 ~ Langlands 21 ~ Wood 45 HF: Lynch 39 ~ Boumann 32 ~ Chiu 11 F: Lockwood 29 ~ Galea 7 ~ O'Shea 44 R: Mulligan 38 ~ Lyons 13 ~ O'Keefe 30 Int: Dickson 16 ~ Quinn 65 ~ Jenkins 69 ~ Miller 61 ~ Tanner 57 ~ Georgiadis 15 ~ Young 52 ~ Knight 55 ~ Post 60 ~ Grossman 49
Forums
CGull Mon, 23 Jun 2008 - 10:29
Sorry,have I missed something here?,when did the tribunal sit and how many weeks did the big bloke get?
iceman Tue, 24 Jun 2008 - 14:31
Geez its good to see Collingwood on the bottom of the ladder.... looking forward to seeing how we stack up in a couple of weeks to Williamstown, who are by far the benchmark.
InForAPenny Tue, 24 Jun 2008 - 16:52
footyman wrote:The Herald Sun today says he was reported by four umpires. That should be good enough to cop weeks, video or no video.
I was at the ground but a fair way from the incident. Cox was running with the flight of the ball and Street was coming the other way. I reckon it's fair to say that they were both trying to mark the ball. I felt they arrived at the ball at almost the same instant. Certainly Street had a legitimate claim to being where he was. It will be interesting to see the outcome. I imagine the tribunal will sit tonight.
InForAPenny Tue, 24 Jun 2008 - 17:01
Dale61 wrote:Four umpires! I bet two of them didn't even see what happened! Anyway, the next 3-4 weeks will really test Williamstown's ruck depth. Scott Meyer was good at times last year, so he may be an option, which could see Barling come in for his first senior game of the season. Barling would take over from Meyer in defence. Cloke could be used, at a pinch, around the ground, but I think Gotchy will now have to devise a plan to rove to the opposition ruckmen at centre bounces.
Dale, Meyer's best ruck work is done at centre bounces where he doesn't have to put body on body with opposing ruckmen. He has a prodigious leap and is known for his spectacular spikes to the forward 50 from centre bounces. Where he sometimes struggles is ball ups around the ground where he lacks to bulk to match it with the bigger guys. At boundary throw ins he often plays off his man using closing speed to gain the tap. This is not always successful though and someone like Cloke as third man up would certainly make a difference. Jackson Barling has started to make his presence felt in the 2's and I reckon he is just about ready to play seniors if required. It all depends on the tribunal first and then the selection table on Thursday.
CGull Wed, 25 Jun 2008 - 12:16
Pardon the obvious bias,the guys I stand with reckon Street would be odds on for the Liston he's been so dominant,does getting suspended now mean he's ineligible as in the Brownlow?
InForAPenny Wed, 25 Jun 2008 - 12:31
Dale61 wrote:I'm sure the Roosters would be pleased to hear that!
Dale, I suspect that they may just already know as he has rucked against them in 2005,6 and 7 and their coach rucked him for a quarter in the state game when his own man (Stephenson) could not get near it.
ExtendtheDUKES Wed, 25 Jun 2008 - 12:49
Quote:Pardon the obvious bias,the guys I stand with reckon Street would be odds on for the Liston he's been so dominant,does getting suspended now mean he's ineligible as in the Brownlow?
Massive chance for the Liston. I think Baird will be really close too. But Street has dominated this year and deserves to be favourite.