Port Melbourne playing list 2007 and general waffle..

Having a bit of a ramble while I watch data move from one server to another here at work... Good to see that the rumours regarding Carlyle were quickly quashed. And plenty of good noises coming out of the Borough for next season. Very much looking forward to Presentation night to see if we have signed up any of possibles coming out of the AFL or Interstate that wish to return or remain in Victoria. Hopefully the club can attract not just the best from Oakleigh and other kids in the TAC cup looking for a club that will give them opportunities at senior level too. Some football followers hate the end of the season prior to the National draft, with player de-listings and trade talk. Personally I find it one of the most interesting parts of the season.. building up hope for the coming season. Will Geelong delist some of those players like Playfair, Gardiner and McCarthy that could still be good options at VFL level. Is Kent Kingsley the sort of player that could dominate in the VFL the way Aaron Edwards has in 2006?
crashlander Sun, 8 Oct 2006 - 15:26
Ons, don't bank of Kent Kingsley. He is a very up and down player whose kicking is unreliable. He also prefers to have good disposal to him: think of a 21st century McKenna without the kicking skills. When he is on fire, he is very good, but he is highly unlikely to stay on fire. Aaron Edwards was a bit of a surprise - people knew he could play but didn't realise he was as good as he turned out to be. He has really good kicking most days. He also had a relatively ordinary year for Fullbacks - very few really good defenders on offer to compete against. Kingsley wouldn't have the surprise factor or the athleticism and is a MUCH worse kick. That doesn't mean he couldn't be a winner. But I cannot see him being as effective as Edwards was.
Dolphin Tue, 10 Oct 2006 - 17:46
crashlander wrote:Aaron Edwards was a bit of a surprise - people knew he could play but didn't realise he was as good as he turned out to be. He has really good kicking most days. He also had a relatively ordinary year for Fullbacks - very few really good defenders on offer to compete against. Kingsley wouldn't have the surprise factor or the athleticism and is a MUCH worse kick. That doesn't mean he couldn't be a winner. But I cannot see him being as effective as Edwards was.
Edwards became a much better player than he was in his years in the West after working with the Dolphins.
theobserver Wed, 11 Oct 2006 - 09:32
``Edwards became a much better player than he was in his years in the West after working with the Dolphins'' Garbage. It was more to do with his attitude. Sure, Frankston had the good sense to play him at full forward - he played in defence in the WAFL - but he basically pulled his head in. He said it himself when the MC interviewed at the Liston dinner...
Dolphin Wed, 11 Oct 2006 - 13:44
theobserver wrote:``Edwards became a much better player than he was in his years in the West after working with the Dolphins'' Garbage. It was more to do with his attitude. Sure, Frankston had the good sense to play him at full forward - he played in defence in the WAFL - but he basically pulled his head in. He said it himself when the MC interviewed at the Liston dinner...
Gee, you make those comments as though you know what went on with and in relation to him. Shame you obviously don't.
theobserver Wed, 11 Oct 2006 - 14:04
Hopefully I get to know him better when Carlton drafts him and he plays with the Bullants next year :wink:
Dolphin Wed, 11 Oct 2006 - 14:08
theobserver wrote:Hopefully I get to know him better when Carlton drafts him and he plays with the Bullants next year :wink:
Yeah, that will be good. Keep bludging off Carlton. Aren't they just the team you would want helping you out. Must be plenty of depth in the old blue list. :wink:
theobserver Wed, 11 Oct 2006 - 15:17
Easy to get a bite out of you today chief :wink: When are you going to answer that question about Lovett's option? I'm intrigued as to how it works...
NorthPort Topic starter Wed, 11 Oct 2006 - 18:04
Anyway steering this vaguely back on topic. The club MUST recruit around 6 Players that are either ex-AFL talent who can still perform at VFL level, or players from the SANFL/WAFL that can play tall in the VFL. We need at least another 2 players at around the 195CM range. Rumours flying everywhere about some exciting signings at Port, but lets wait to see them sign on the dotted line first. I hope the club really promotes the signings if and when they do happen. We need a lot of promotion to build up to a competitive 2007.
footyman Wed, 11 Oct 2006 - 21:34
onslaught wrote:Rumours flying everywhere about some exciting signings at Port, but lets wait to see them sign on the dotted line first. I hope the club really promotes the signings if and when they do happen. We need a lot of promotion to build up to a competitive 2007.
Its no rumour Ons, you told me there were two done deals!!!!!!