Werribee No Hope Without Tommo

Nathan Thompson won't play for the Tigers against Port this weekend. I'd have given them a huge chance if he was in, but without him it becomes that little bit more difficult. Port should win, however, doubts have been cast after last weeks return from their break. Thoughts?
Forums
footyman Wed, 30 Jul 2008 - 23:14
He's only played one match for them this year, they've won 8 others without him in their side. If they need Nathan Thompson to be there to be guaranteed of a win they may as well give up now. I do agree to some extent that if you look at it Werribee have Pods out in front with 53 goals for the year, then its way back into the 'teens' headed by Leigh Brown. Another spearhead in their forward line may be a good thing, but they've got a strong enough group of mids to kick the bob up and kick goals. Werribee accounted for Port earlier this year, when arguably they werent travelling as well as they are now. Werribee have hit a purple patch of form, have just had a freshen up and Port went down disappointingly to Frankston last weekend. Port may still be too good - but Werribee have a good core group of VFL listed players in that side. Not over by a long shot. Should be the TV game, its definately the best game of the round.
MinkaBeaver Wed, 30 Jul 2008 - 23:25
footyman wrote:He's only played one match for them this year, they've won 8 others without him in their side. If they need Nathan Thompson to be there to be guaranteed of a win they may as well give up now. I do agree to some extent that if you look at it Werribee have Pods out in front with 53 goals for the year, then its way back into the 'teens' headed by Leigh Brown. Another spearhead in their forward line may be a good thing, but they've got a strong enough group of mids to kick the bob up and kick goals. Werribee accounted for Port earlier this year, when arguably they werent travelling as well as they are now. Werribee have hit a purple patch of form, have just had a freshen up and Port went down disappointingly to Frankston last weekend. Port may still be too good - but Werribee have a good core group of VFL listed players in that side. Not over by a long shot. Should be the TV game, its definately the best game of the round.
Has to be mentioned that Werribee have just played four home games in a row - might give a false impression of their overall season when judging just the last month. I agree that Brown is the wildcard for the Tigers, but their recent form has also been because of solid support in the ruck from Todd Goldstein and young Andrew Banjanin. For mine, Goldstein will be a bigger loss for their structure than Nathan Thompson. A lot depends on their run from defence. They have recently been quick in transition, and have some 'lead up' forwards like Ben Warren and Michael Barlow who give space and delivery to the Pods. But to hit these leads they require guys like Scott Howard and Teghan Henderson to provide the dash. They defeated Casey with Henderson out for the first time in several years because of work commitments; I don't think they can afford to lose him or Howard terribly often though. There's no real star at Werribee, despite the often fawning attention given to Podsiadly (no doubt I'm as guilty as most of playing up his impact). That midfield of Ross, Davies, Gleeson and Castello is not necessarily able to match up that of, say, Williamstown, but is more than a match for the rest of the competition.
footyman Wed, 30 Jul 2008 - 23:32
MinkaBeaver wrote:Has to be mentioned that Werribee have just played four home games in a row - might give a false impression of their overall season when judging just the last month. I agree that Brown is the wildcard for the Tigers, but their recent form has also been because of solid support in the ruck from Todd Goldstein and young Andrew Banjanin. For mine, Goldstein will be a bigger loss for their structure than Nathan Thompson. A lot depends on their run from defence. They have recently been quick in transition, and have some 'lead up' forwards like Ben Warren and Michael Barlow who give space and delivery to the Pods. But to hit these leads they require guys like Scott Howard and Teghan Henderson to provide the dash. They defeated Casey with Henderson out for the first time in several years because of work commitments; I don't think they can afford to lose him or Howard terribly often though. There's no real star at Werribee, despite the often fawning attention given to Podsiadly (no doubt I'm as guilty as most of playing up his impact). That midfield of Ross, Davies, Gleeson and Castello is not necessarily able to match up that of, say, Williamstown, but is more than a match for the rest of the competition.
Terrific summary! I guess Werribee would be licking their lips too at the prospect of playing Collingwood, Box Hill and Bendigo after this week. They obviously dropped a game to BH earlier this year, but its a pretty friendly draw and makes the top four realistic for them - even with their shocking percentage. Who knows, they might play Williamstown in Rd 20 and then again the following week in a final.
Dolphin Thu, 31 Jul 2008 - 00:00
footyman wrote:Port went down disappointingly to Frankston last weekend.
I wasn't dissapointed.
bcarbonaro Thu, 31 Jul 2008 - 12:16
TheVoiceoftheB wrote:Nathan Thompson won't play for the Tigers against Port this weekend. I'd have given them a huge chance if he was in, but without him it becomes that little bit more difficult. Port should win, however, doubts have been cast after last weeks return from their break. Thoughts?
I reckon even without him we can still get over the line. Podsiadly's form in recent weeks has been very good and Brown has been a good addition to our side as well.
Goss_Marauder Thu, 31 Jul 2008 - 14:43
I reckon this weekend's game is a telling one for Port. Was last week's loss to Frankston an aberration, or is the mid-year purple patch over? I agree with most people here that Thompson's absence will not determine the outcome of this game - he didn't play last time the teams met and Werribee managed to win.
bcarbonaro Thu, 31 Jul 2008 - 15:47
Yes, the theory that we would need Thompson as our key forward to win the game is a myth.