If you could create a midfield made of up players from any team in the VFL, who would you pick and why?
I think many of us would agree Peter Street has led the way this year in the ruck. That's an easy selection for me.
Brett Johnson is a midfielder I've long respected, perhaps the guy having a terrific season under Gary Ayres for Port Melbourne in Toby Pinwill and Adam Iacobucci? Tom Roach? Al Neville hasnt had the impact this year in a weaker side. They're perhaps all similar type builds, take someone out and throw someone in their for pace?
Anybody want to give an opinion?
Forums
I think this has to be a VFL listed midfield, doesn't it? In which case, Street shouldn't qualify.
With that criterion in mind, I'll have a quick stab and give them some positions (because I can :D ):
Ruck - Orren Stephenson. (If you'd asked me twelve months ago, it would've been Travis Ronaldson; a big loss for the competition and Coburg).
Centre - Peter Summers
Ruck-rover - Brett Johnson
Rover - David Spriggs
Happy for people to pluck anybody from any team, AFL listed or not so long as they regularly play VFL (as Street does)! But we may as well go with your criterion and make it for solely VFL listed players.
Agree with you on Ronaldson, for an undersized ruckman he always had the ability to not only compete with, but beat what he was up against.
There aren't a lot of genuinely good quality rucks on VFL lists this year. I guess most AFL clubs have four or five guys on their list (inc rookies) and at any one time have two or three in the VFL system. Sandringham for example really havent needed a ruckman with White, Spencer, Meeson running around there recently.
Happy for people to pluck anybody from any team, AFL listed or not so long as they regularly play VFL (as Street does)! But we may as well go with your criterion and make it for solely VFL listed players.
Agree with you on Ronaldson, for an undersized ruckman he always had the ability to not only compete with, but beat what he was up against.
There aren't a lot of genuinely good quality rucks on VFL lists this year. I guess most AFL clubs have four or five guys on their list (inc rookies) and at any one time have two or three in the VFL system. Sandringham for example really havent needed a ruckman with White, Spencer, Meeson running around there recently.[/quote]
Sorry to hijack it, maybe there's a case for naming both a VFL-listed and AFL-listed quartet?
I liked Ronaldson's physicality. He owned front position at the throw-ins; very hard to get past some of the broadest shoulders going around.
There will no doubt be some good rucks coming through the system. Some lesser lights such as Peder Whelan (Frankston) and Andrew Banjanin (Werribee) are players to watch for, while Dylan McLaren and David Fanning have proven to be a very solid combination for Port Melbourne.
Go for your life, Im hijacking the Big V pamphlet threads so you can do what you like with my threads!!! Give us your best AFL listed quartet.
[quote:8fb3af15cf="MinkaBeaver"]
There will no doubt be some good rucks coming through the system. Some lesser lights such as Peder Whelan (Frankston) and Andrew Banjanin (Werribee) are players to watch for, while Dylan McLaren and David Fanning have proven to be a very solid combination for Port Melbourne.[/quote]
Agree, but its funny the guys you mentioned come from stand alone or partially aligned clubs. There probably is one, but who holds the number 1 ruck title as a VFL listed player in a club that is aligned? You see more VFL than what I do.
Bullants - Hampson
Bendigo - Bellchambers
Willy - Street
Sandringham - White
Casey - Rix (Gardiner?)
Coburg - Cartledge
Box Hill - Taylor
John Baird (for midfield of the year) anyone?
Orren Stephenson is the Roosters Number 1 ruckman and holds his own rather well, especially against the 3 AFL listed rucks Geelong had in West Mumford and Dawson Simpson..
My best VFL Midfield would be
Stephenson
Skipworth
Spriggs
Iaccabouci
Roach & Stretton on the outside
And AFL Listed
Cartledge
Grima
Byrnes
Yze
Sansbury and Cotchin on the outside
Note that this is only from what i have seen at VFL level so no disrespect to sides i haven't seen this year!