You wont see this brought up in the media but I recon Patrick Rose was very harshly treated at the Bulldogs.
I always rated him a good player but seeing him up close at Port hes easily the best small forward in the state.

I honestly think he was not given any opportunity at the Western Bulldogs because of a personality clash. The whispers were that Eade told him he needed more strings to his bow to play AFL and he needed to become a midfielder.

But one thing the dogs have is midfielders. Why would they need another when when they have 10-15 blokes they could run through the middle?

Yet when the finals come around the Western Bulldogs and the coach himself said they were desperate to find a small forward and even gave a debut to Andrew Hooper in the most import game of the season. Very strange to me.

He will kick close to 70-80 goals this season if he plays all the matches and could be still on the radar of a few AFL clubs.

And no I am not a mate or relative of Rose. Just an observer.

Forums
Wally from Wil… Sun, 8 May 2011 - 22:12

Rose is having an excellent season, despite his apparent rib injury. I've still been unable to determine why Willi let him slip away so easily when his talent is beyond doubt. I can only put it down to him wanting too much money or other benefits after he believed his AFL chances were over, or to the perception that he was unreliable in finals, as alluded to on here by Gullsghost. I'm really looking forward to next Saturday's clash, but it will be painful watching him, Galea & Brewer playing against us, plus the other guys that have played for Willi such as Skipper & Fanning.

vfa Sun, 8 May 2011 - 22:27

Next week's Port v Williamstown clash will be a beauty. Plenty of ex seagulls playing for Port which adds to this top of the table between the two oldest and most successful VFA teams. Both have had great starts to the season and are unbeaten. Patrick Rose and Dean Galea have both had good seasons to date. With possible rain for most of the week could be a tough clash and most likely Teac Oval will be rated a slow 7 (in racing terms). Looking forward to this game.

burraburger Topic starter Mon, 9 May 2011 - 16:48

I'm aware of the rookie list rules Dale but he didn't play NAB cup or practice games either. Liam Picken was given every opportunity after williamstown contributed his wage for a rookie list spot. Rose didn't get a look in. And there's no chance it was a fitness issue.

digs Mon, 9 May 2011 - 17:29

burraburger wrote:I'm aware of the rookie list rules Dale but he didn't play NAB cup or practice games either. Liam Picken was given every opportunity after williamstown contributed his wage for a rookie list spot. Rose didn't get a look in. And there's no chance it was a fitness issue.

How was the relationship between German & Rose ???
Did Rose go to the Bulldogs under the same arrangement as Picken. ie Williamstown subsudising to his rookie listing ???

burraburger Topic starter Mon, 9 May 2011 - 17:54

Same arrangement digs. Id suggest his relationship with the coaches may have been similar to that of Jeremy Clayton and Dean Laidley.